The Phenomenology of Kotal Ritual in Bakhtiari Tribe

Document Type : Research Paper

Author

Assistant Professor, Department of Social Sciences, Payam-e Nour University, Tehran, Iran.

Abstract

Introduction

Rituals are an integral part of any society's culture. In today's modern world, human beings are still dominated by religions and beliefs that have their roots in the distant past, and according to Karl Jaspers, human beings today are still indebted to a pivotal period in history; A period in which the ancient religions of the world emerged from the corners of the world in almost a single period and have affected our lives to this day (Jasper, 1998, p. 55). In our society, Rituals, especially mourning Rituals, are formed from pieces of ancient Iran, Islamic culture, and modern world ideas, which have a certain breadth and dynamism and affect a large part of our behavior (Moradkhani and Ghobadi, 2011, p.94). In Dezful city, every year we see rituals that carry a special meaning for the people of each nation. One of these rituals is the Kotal ritual, which is common among the Bakhtiari Tribe living in this city. The present study seeks to answer the questions in a phenomenological way: when does the historical and mythological background of this religion date back to? How is it implemented? What is the experience of people participating in this ritual? How do they understand its meaning and understanding?

Methodology

The present research has utilized a qualitative approach and phenomenological method. The studied population includes 17 people who participated in this ritual between 2015 and 2019. Data were collected using the in-depth interview and purposive sampling methods. For the data analysis, the participants' statements were first recorded and implemented, then carefully listened to and studied several times by the researcher.

Discussion

Findings showed that social identity is the product of interactions between different groups. Through rituals, people interact with each other and provide themselves with a fixed identity and point of reliance amid inconsistencies and beliefs, thereby obtaining a sense of identity through getting to know themselves. In this regard, the actions and rites that people perform in this ritual cause their thoughts and beliefs to be connected and aligned. It also creates a kind of social contract in which individuals, through voluntary cooperation, express their efforts to flourish their capabilities for the benefit of the organization or community. Finally, participants believe that in addition to joy and happiness, life also has sufferings and difficulties. Participation in this religion causes the formation of faith in human beings and by interpreting bitterness correctly, it sweetens it, and by leading humans to believe in the resurrection, any pain and suffering inflicted by nature or others, the Almighty God will make up for it in a different way.

Conclusion

The findings show that this ritual goes back to the mourning of Siavash, which is especially evident in the ritual of burying the dead. Participants experience a sense of peace of mind by standing together and guarding their social identity; accordingly, society will seek to maintain identity patterns by expanding the social space and removing social barriers and restrictions for different social strata. Despite valuing sorrow, grief, and suffering, the Kotal ritual has institutionalized social and cultural relations and connects generations, passing beliefs, rituals, and oral literature from the past to the present. Participants' behaviors, practices, and etiquettes during the ritual play a meaningful role in the participants' lives. Overally, the participation of the goal community in the Kotal ritual has a mythological-historical background. With voluntary and spontaneous participation in these rituals, participants seek to give meaning to life while seeking and identifying with their peers.  This group of people also strengthens their resilience and tolerance in the face of life's difficulties. In addition, creating unity and strengthening the spirit of solidarity is one of the social functions of individuals' participation in collective rituals and ceremonies; the continuity of Kotal ritual is the proof of this claim.

Keywords


- Azkia, M., & Ghafari, GH. (2001). The relationship between trust and social participation in the villages of Kashan County. Journal of Social Sciences Letter. 17(17), 3-31. (in Persian)
- Bates, D., & Plog, F. (2011). Cultural Anthropology (9th ed.). (M. Salasi, Trans.). Tehran: Elmi Publications. (in Persian)
- Bell, C. (1992). Ritual Theory, Ritual Practice. New York: Oxford University Press. (in English)
- Ershadi Farsani, A. (2009). Ritual of Kotal Bandoon in Bakhtiari Tribe. Najvaye Farhang. 13, 49-54. (in Persian)
- Fakouhi, N. (2019). History of Anthropological Thought and Theories (12th ed.). Tehran: Ney Publication. (in Persian)
- Geertz, C, (2004). “Religion as a cultural System”, in M. Banton (ed) Anthropological Approaches to the study of Religion, A.S.A. Monographs no.3, London. (in English)
- Ghaemi, F. (2014). Criticism and analysis of the ritual structure of Siavash myth. Literary Criticism. 25. 153-184. (in Persian)
- Ghebadi, A., & Alipour, P. (2012). Functional analysis of religious ceremony and rituals. Biannual Journal of Islam and Social Sciences. 4(8). 84-92. (in Persian)
- Gholipour, S. (2017). Anthropology of Sog (Pers) in Kakavand Tribe. Iranian Journal of Anthropology. 15(27). 125-147. (in Persian)
- Gilani, N., & Gilani, A. (2015). Analytical and comparative studying of Lurish and Kurdish mourning rituals of Siavash in comparison with tradition of mourning in Shahnameh. Journal of Iranian Regional Languages and Literature. 4(1), 181-202. (in Persian)
- Glaser, B., and Anselm S. (1967). The Discovery of Grounded Theory: Strategies for Qualitative Research, Aldine Transaction. (in English)
- Hosouri, A. (2005). Siavoshan (2nd ed.). Tehran: Cheshemeh Publication. (in Persian)
- Jaspers, K. (1994). The Origin and Goal of History (M. Latifi, Trans.). (2nd ed.). Tehran: Kharazmi Publications. (in Persian)
- Latifpour, A. (2006). A History of Dezful. Tehran: Farhang Maktoub Publications. (in Persian)
- Madadi, H. (1999). Kotal ritual: a display of secrets and senses in Bakhtiari Tribe. Namayesh. 19(14). 56-59. (in Persian)
- Meskoub, S. (1972). Siavash's Mourning: Death and Resurrection. Tehran: Kharazmi Publications. (in Persian)
- Mircea, E. (2015). A Dissertation on the History of Religions (J. Sattari, Trans.). Tehran: Soroush Publication. (in Persian)
- Mohl, J. (1990). Ferdowsi's Shahnameh (J. Afkari, Compiled.). (Vol. 2). Tehran: Jibi. (in Persian)
- Moradkhani, S., & Ghobadi, P. (2011). Mourning ritual in Kakavand Tribe. Journal of Iranian People's Culture. 26, 94-120. (in Persian)
- Morshedzad, A. (2008). Symbols and Rituals in Iran after the Revolution and their role in national unity. Journal of National Studies. 4, 73-98. (in Persian)
- Pals, D. (2003). Seven Theories of Religion (M.A. Bakhtiairi, Trans.). Qom: Imam Khomeini Education and Research Institute. (in Persian)
- Ritzer, G. (2010). Contemporary Sociological Theory and Its Classical Roots (S. Masmi Parast, Trans.). Tehran: Sales Publication. (in Persian)
- Riviere, C. (2007). Political Anthropology (3rd ed.). (N. Fakouhi, Trans.). Tehran: Ney Publication. (in Persian)
- Rothenbuhler, E. (2008). Ritual Communication: From Everyday Conversation to Mediated Ceremony (A. Givian, Trans.). Tehran: Imam Sadiq University. (in Persian)
- Salehpour, Z. (2007). Horse in Iranian culture. Najvaye Farhang. 2(4). 155-162. (in Persian)
- Stephenson, B. (2018). Ritual: A Very Short Introduction (D. Rezapour, Trans.). Tehran: Hekmat Publication. (in Persian)